phd research proposal gender Sex Gender Discrimination Overview FindLaw.
Gender discrimination essay conclusions thesis statement for process essay thesis statement for process SlidePlayer Discrimination essay our work Essay On.
Fighting gender discrimination essay Texprep essay Fighting gender discrimination essay Texprep essay Millicent Rogers Museum All.
Gender discrimination essay conclusions Copy Transform Combine.
Thesis statement for gender discrimination College essays Domov Inequality Essays Personal Response Essay Personal Response Essays.
Thesis quiz AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News Essay on gender issues Essay examination Academic essay Essay Exam Rubric Excelsior College Essay examination Academic.
William Bradford Essay Outline Thesis Statement William SlideShare.
essay on gender discrimination lok lehrte.
thesis on gender Bienvenidos.
essays on gender discrimination we write high quality homework essays on gender discrimination.
gender essays gender roles essay persuasive essays female and male phd thesis on gender discrimination uk.
Thesis Statement For Gender Discrimination In The Workplace.
Thesis quiz Carpinteria Rural Friedrich Sex Gender Discrimination Overview FindLaw.
Thesis of brave new world Design Synthesis Gender discrimination in the workplace essays on global warming a word expository essay powerpoint.
essay thesis critical analysis essay thesis statement a thesis nmctoastmasters Fighting gender discrimination essay Texprep essay Fighting gender discrimination essay Texprep essay Millicent Rogers Museum All.
Thesis statement for gender discrimination College essays Essay about lee kuan yew English Homework Writing Help DEMO Gap in Gender Pay Why Men.
phd research proposal gender Women discrimination in the workplace essay kidakitap com.
Gender Roles Thesis Statement by Ezgi ak r on Prezi.
Thesis statement on racism and discrimination Ascend Surgical.
Research paper gender discrimination in the workplace Research All About Essay Example Galle Co racial discrimination Thesis statement .
gender essays gender roles essay persuasive essays female and male .
Related Post of Gender discrimination in workplace essay .
Gender discrimination in the workplace thesis proposal Gender discrimination in the workplace thesis proposal.
Essays on workplace discrimination.
Gender discrimination at workplace sociology essays TES Gender discrimination at workplace sociology essays TES Ascend Surgical.
Section I Entrepreneurship and supporting institutions Design Synthesis.
images about essay writing on thesis statement images about essay writing on thesis statement persuasive.
thesis on gender Thesis American Values Zoot Suit Luiz Valdez Gender discrimination in the workplace thesis writing as with.
GENDER AND VIDEO GAMES ADAM SHAFFER Introduction of topic Video AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News medea essay medea essay oglasi medea essay oglasi medea essays medea essay topics odol my ip.
Workplace discrimination thesis statement Thesis statement on religious discrimination thesis persuasive essay atsl my ip mepersuasive thesis statement generator thesis.
Thesis of brave new world Thesis From the show.
Thesis statement on discrimination in the workplace Karate Dojo Hochbahn Thesis statement for gender pay gap personal essay thesis statement www gxart orgwhat is a personal.
Thesis Statement by Sierra Harkins on Prezi.
gender discrimination essays lok lehrte All About Essay Example Research proposal gender discrimination in the work place Myers Audio Boutique Amps and Pedalboards.
Research paper gender discrimination in the workplace Research All About Essay Example Galle Co racial discrimination Thesis statement INPIEQ.
Gender Discrimination Essay EssayGlobe.
Thesis statement practice ESL Energiespeicherl sungen.
a thesis statement on drugs buy essay online get best quality drug consumption is a single.
format for proposals.
essay of gender discrimination .
essay of gender discrimination batasweb sexual discrimination essayessays on w strength of a w essay brain drain short essay length discrimination.
Thesis statement on religious discrimination.
AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
essay thesis definition and examples of thesis statement narrative Thesis Statement good thesis statement about gender roles Gender roles essay thesis statement pdfeports web fc com Gender.
essay on gender equality gcse miscellaneous marked by teachers compage zoom in rokumdns.
Sex discrimination in the workplace essay why looks are the last bastion of discrimination thesis statement AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
discrimination employment thesis Carpinteria Rural Friedrich gender discrimination essay gender discrimination essay wwwgxart Home.
Gender Roles Thesis Statement by Ezgi ak r on Prezi AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
thesis statement on abortion partial abortion thesis thesis statement on why abortion is wrong yahoo answers INPIEQ.
Novel thesis statement Design Synthesis.
Essays On Gender Education In Essay Out Of Play Critical Essays On.
Discrimination Essay Thesis Statement Thesis statement for racial discrimination us essay online ayUCar com.
thesis statement for gender pay gap SlidePlayer good thesis for gender roles Thesis statement about gender roles good thesis statement about gender roles FarSite.
Discrimination employment thesis.
A Male Manager .
Thesis statement on discrimination in the workplace essay on gender equality gcse miscellaneous marked by teachers compage zoom in.
gender discrimination essays lok lehrte INPIEQ.
Gender discrimination thesis statement ontheroofs com.
good thesis statement about gender roles Gender roles essay thesis statement pdfeports web fc com Gender.
Novel thesis statement bihap com Bihap com.
Gender discrimination in workplace essay Discrimination thesis statement ipgproje com UNT Digital Library University of North Texas Discrimination thesis statement ipgproje com UNT Digital Library .
thesis statement examples essays help with thesis best resume where is a thesis statement in an Thesis Statement.
Thesis statement for gender discrimination College essays gender inequality papers photoroulette tk gender inequality papers photoroulette tk.
format for proposals.
discrimination employment thesis Untitled Prezi.
gender discrimination essays gender discrimination essays wwwgxart Essay On Gender Discrimination In India An Analysis Of The N.
Argumentative Essay on Discrimination Discrimination Woman free moral dilemma essays and papers helpmetable i codes and About Essay Example The Crucible Essay On John Proctor Success .
thesis on gender.
Sex discrimination in the workplace essay why looks are the last bastion of discrimination thesis statement.
term paper on gender inequality Ascend Surgical.
Thesis statement on religious discrimination From the show.
Sex discrimination in the workplace essay why looks are the last bastion of discrimination thesis statement.
Discrimination Essay Thesis Statement Thesis statement for Gender essay thesis Reasons to Write Mutual fund flows and gender biases in Scandinavia empirical evidence.
Thesis AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Essays on workplace discrimination AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Gender roles essay thesis statement drugerreport web fc com .
Thesis on discrimination in the workplace.
Short essay on gender bias LeoFit.
Thesis on Gender Inequality State Your Point Design Synthesis.
thesis statement examples for narrative essays thesis statement .
historical argument essay topics Gender discrimination in the workplace thesis proposal Gender discrimination in the workplace thesis proposal.
thesis statement for persuasive essay dnnd my ip mech reading and writing argument essays an argument Ascend Surgical.
essays on job discrimination AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
essay on gender discrimination lok lehrte Thesis Statement Examples to Inspire Your Next Argumentative Thesis Statement Examples to Inspire Your Next Argumentative.
gender essay essay on gender equality gcse miscellaneous marked by .
Discrimination Essay Thesis Statement Thesis statement for gender discrimination.
Gender discrimination in the workplace essays on global warming a word expository essay powerpoint .
William Bradford Essay Outline Thesis Statement William Design Synthesis.
AMERICAN ASSOCIATION FOR ADVANCEMENT OF SCIENCE (AAAS) PROCLAIMS GENDER BIAS IN PEER REVIEW WITHOUT EVIDENCE
AAAS hosted a conference in April, 2016, which presentation after presentation by famous, influential, and prestigious scientists argued for the power and prevalence of implicit gender biases in peer review. Yet not a shred of evidence of implicit bias in peer review was actually presented. Just read this report – you can see for yourselves that there was ample evidence of gaps, but none that bias accounted for those gaps. And if you believe that “gap=discrimination,” you are wrong (please read my prior blog on the topic).
Now, that AAAS report is basically a news article, not a peer reviewed scientific article. So I contacted two attendees of the conference. I knew one personally – Simine Vazire -- and consider her to be an extremely reasonable and thoughtful scientist. I hate disagreeing with Simine, but, if I have to disagree with someone, it would be Simine – because she is one of few people I have ever met capable of disagreeing without becoming insulting or hostile. Our exchange on sex bias in social psychology might be of interest to many readers of this blog.
So I asked her the bluntest of all possible questions:
“I am about to write a blog claiming that, at the AAAS conference you attended, no one presented a shred of evidence that bias explains any of the gaps that were discussed. I do not want to make that statement if it is not true. Is it true?” She confirmed, via email, that, in her view, it was a true statement, although she also pointed out that “unconscious bias” was not her main scientific area of research.
The AAAS article also included this: “’Studies of the peer-review process have shown that African-Americans and women ‘are held to higher standards to be judged competent,’ said Molly Carnes, a professor of medicine, psychiatry, and industrial & systems engineering at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.”
“Aha!” I thought, “Now I can get to the bottom of this. Just because the attendees didn’t present evidence of gender or race bias in peer review, it does not mean the evidence doesn’t exist! It must be that the evidence is so overwhelming, so conclusive, that the presenters simply took it for granted that any reasonable scholar attending would be thoroughly familiar with the abundant evidence.” So, figuring that anyone with familiarity with the area would know such evidence cold and could direct me to it, I emailed Dr. Carnes a request to identify the studies to which she referred.
As it turned out, this was not the simple slam dunk it seemed at first glance.
FAILED ATTEMPT I
Dr. Carnes wrote back to me:
“Much of this work comes from Monica Biernat at University of Kansas. She refers to the phenomenon as ‘shifting standards of reference. I have attached some.”
Now, this was amusingly ironic – I went to grad school with Monica Biernat, and was there when she developed the ideas and initial studies that became her work on shifting standards. I know that work pretty well. Here is the kicker, though: Monica has never published a single study of the peer review process.
However, Dr. Carnes also sent me this paper of hers (Kaatz et al, 2015, published in Academic Medicine). Here is one of the key conclusions, quoted directly from the paper: “Critiques showed differences due to applicant sex despite similar application scores or funding outcomes: more praise for applications from female investigators, greater reference to competence/ability for funded applications from female experienced investigators, and more negative evaluation words for applications from male investigators (all P < .05).”
People are more likely to criticize and less likely to praise those for whom they hold higher standards. Carnes’ paper acknowledges this: “Such gender bias may be unconscious and derives from pervasive cultural stereotypes that women have lower competence than men in fields like academic medicine and science where men have historically predominated.” So, who received more criticism and less praise for similar quality applications? Men! Put differently, Dr. Carnes’ own research produced a result exactly opposite to the one that she was promoting at the AAAS Conference! Women were held to lower, not higher, standards than men to warrant praise.
FAILED ATTEMPT II
So, I contacted Dr. Carnes again. This time, I wrote,
“Thanks for sending those along, but I am confused. I did not see anything here by Biernat on peer review. Do you? Or is there some other reference?”
Then I also pointed out that her own paper showed a result opposite to her claim. I ended with this:
“Thanks in advance for whatever clarifications you can provide.”
After agreeing that Biernat never studied peer review, she went on to explain the result from her paper as follows:
“The Kaatz paper shows similar scores for men and women but greater praise and acclamation for women's proposals. This is an observational rather than experimental study, but it aligns with experimental work indicating that even though women may receive higher verbal acclaim for their work, they are less likely to have this accompanied by tangible rewards such as promotion, hiring, raise, or - perhaps in this case - a grant score.”
Right. They found women were held to lower standards with respect to receipt of praise and criticism. Now, one might argue that, “Aha! This is bias! People have low expectations and standards for women scientists!” And that might be a valid point, and it would be interesting if it led to lower levels of funding for women. But the Kaatz et al paper reported no actual results comparing male and female researchers’ outcomes. In seeking to explain their results, it did, however, include this curious statement: “This could be one interpretation of the comparable scores and funding outcomes for male and female investigators…” What can this (“comparable scores and funding outcomes”) possibly mean other than “We found no gender bias in funding outcomes”?
Women might be held to higher standards or they might be held to lower standards. Either might be common or general, or specific and contingent (maybe women are held to higher standards in some situations, and lower standards in other situations). But one cannot cite evidence of women being held to lower standards as evidence that they are held to higher standards.
SEMI-FAILED ATTEMPT III
However, Dr. Carnes also sent me another paper. This one really was on peer review, and it really did show sex bias favoring men. Women had to be much more productive than men to get an equal rating. In the mid-1990s. In Sweden. When applying for postdocs.
So why have I cast this as a “semi-failed” attempt to get the data? Let’s contrast the original claim with the data supporting it so far:
Claim, made at AAAS conference, in 2016: “Studies of the peer-review process have shown that African-Americans and women ‘are held to higher standards to be judged competent"
A single study of peer review of postdoc applications in Sweden, in the mid-1990s, showed bias against women.
FAILED ATTEMPT IV, PART I: “VARYING CONCLUSIONS”
“It Ain’t What You Don’t Know That Gets You Into Trouble. It’s What You Know For Sure That Just Ain’t So.” (Mark Twain)
I sent Dr. Carnes one last email:
“Thanks for sending that paper on Swedish grant reviews from the 1990s. I am wondering if you know of anything else? Say, something in the U.S. or in journal reviews?”
Dr. Carnes graciously replied yet again. Her email included a striking admission:
“There are a number of studies that have looked at grant awards with varying conclusions about gender bias.”
I did not ask her the following question: “If the conclusions are varying, then why were you quoted as claiming that the studies supported one specific conclusion, that peer review is [supposedly] biased against women and African Americans, without mentioning that there were also studies showing no bias or reverse bias?
Now, this would all be a trivial issue if Dr. Carnes was a unique outlier, or if her views were not taken seriously. But none of this is true. Her claims all occurred at a major conference sponsored by a major scientific organization. She was invited, presumably, because AAAS considered her an important expert on this topic.
I sent Dr. Carnes a draft of this blog, requesting that she tell me anything I had gotten wrong and offering her an opportunity to post a guest blog in reply. I also informed her when this post went live, repeating those offers. As of this writing, I have not received a reply.
And, as we shall see in my next post on this topic, rather than being an idiosyncratic outlier, this sort of thing is commonplace, when scientists allow their political agendas to drive their claims about science -- in general, but also specifically, with respect to explanations for gender gaps in STEM.
A follow up on this post appears here:
Gender Bias in Science?
If you are interested in these, you may also be interested in:
Why Do Brilliant Girls Tend to Prefer Non-Stem Careers?
The Google Memo
As usual, please familiarize yourself with my comment guidelines before posting. In short, no snark, sarcasm, or insults, and please stay on topic.
Follow us on Twitter for new blog postings and links on science reform, scientific dysfunction, political distortions of science, threats to academic freedom and freedom of speech, and the value of intellectual diversity
Source: Lee Jussim, my daughter Kayla in a computer flight simulator